The Species of Universalism

A multi-lane highway disappearing into thick fog, with the title The Species of Universalism set in the upper left.
Photo by Markus Spiske on Unsplash

    When someone hears the word universalist, they tend to picture just one kind of thing. But there are a bunch of "universalisms," and while they all agree on the outcome, they differ on the means.

    So let's sort them. Picture a line. At one end, human freedom settles our fate: whatever happens to us in the end, we chose it. At the other end, God's sovereignty settles it: God decides, and God gets whatever God wants. The Christian universalisms sit at different points along that line. And if you keep going past either end, you fall off into something that isn't Christian universalism anymore.

    Let's start with the version most people picture when they hear the word.

    Pop universalism

    Brad Jersak calls this first one pop universalism. It's universalism with no real means and no real ends. All paths lead to God. You don't need Christ or Jesus at all. Everyone gets swallowed up into a vague, nice-guy divine figure, and there are no consequences for anything you did in this life.

    I can't imagine that people who believe this have given it too much thought. Because if you stop and think for one second the very next question is, what about injustice? What about people who have done horrendous things? Or not even horrendous things, just people who have harmed anybody else at all?

    Is the message of universalism, even with a Christian spin on it, that it doesn't matter what you do, everything's going to end up all right? If so, I don't know how you say that to someone who's been abused at the hands of another.

    The locked door

    Before getting to the universalisms proper, it helps to see the edge of the map on the freedom side. This is the view that God does in fact desire that everyone would be saved and join the new heavens and new earth, but free will means that just won't be the case. C. S. Lewis put it this way in The Problem of Pain: the doors of hell are "locked on the inside." God doesn't throw anyone in. People keep themselves out, forever.

    You could call this a free-will universalism, since God's desire is universal. But the outcome isn't, and universalism is a claim about the outcome. So this is where universalism stops.

    N. T. Wright gestures at a version of this in Surprised by Hope. He suggests that people who keep worshiping idols stop bearing God's image, until they become "beings that once were human but now are not." In that case you could say "all humans" are saved, because the ones who resisted God's mercy as long as they could aren't anything recognizably human anymore. They don't count against God's total victory. Kind of a loophole.

    Wright himself doesn't call this universalism, though. He offers it as an alternative to universalism. It belongs here with Lewis, at the place where freedom is real enough to unmake a person.

    Hopeful universalism

    The first real universalism on our line is the hopeful kind. You might hear it called agnostic universalism. We can make assumptions based on God's character: God isn't going to willingly send anybody to eternal conscious torment, or even to annihilation. The door to reconciliation is always open.

    Theologians are going to leave that door open for two different reasons, and the reasons rest on two different kinds of freedom.

    The first is human freedom. Maybe someone could choose separation from God eternally, and God won't override their will. Hans Urs von Balthasar's Dare We Hope "That All Men Be Saved"? lives here. We're allowed to hope hell is empty, maybe even obligated to, but we can't declare it a settled fact.

    The second reason is God's freedom. This is a kind of epistemological humility that says, I don't feel free to bind God's hands and say God must let everyone into the new heavens and the new earth. So my universalism has to be hopeful, because who am I to say God could not act otherwise? Karl Barth is the big name here. His doctrine of election, with Christ as the one chosen and the one rejected on behalf of everybody, seems to point straight at everyone being saved. Barth still wouldn't say it, because he wouldn't put God under a rule.

    Restorationist universalism

    Then you've got universalism in the vein of Origen. Origen did in fact believe in hell, he just didn't believe hell was the end of the story.

    For Origen, creatures (humans, angels, demons) would all have to go through some amount of purgation. Some of them, the stubborn ones, resist being made wholly good, resist being returned to their original form as God's good creation. Hell is where those who resist the love and mercy of God end up, and they may be there a very long time. Origen thinks in ages: epochs upon epochs, eras upon eras, until at last they relent and give themselves up to God's mercy. The word for where it all ends up is ἀποκατάστασις (apokatastasis), restoration, the same word Peter uses in Acts 3:21 when he talks about "the restoration of all things" (ἀποκαταστάσεως πάντων, apokatastaseos panton).

    Then there's Satan. Did Origen think even the devil would be restored? The record cuts both ways. In a letter to friends in Alexandria, Origen complained that an opponent had misrepresented him as teaching that the devil would be saved. Jerome, on the other hand, reports Origen arguing that the devil fell by his own will, not because of some evil nature, and so can be saved. That little word "can" puts Origen himself right on the line between hopeful and convinced universalism. It's also possible that some of the bolder ideas came from Origen's followers more than from Origen, but that's a different topic.

    If Origen makes you nervous because the church later condemned him, Gregory of Nyssa is in this camp too, and he's a canonized saint. In his Catechetical Oration, Gregory compares God's judgment to fire purging gold of its impurities, and he extends that healing even to the one who first brought evil into the world. Isaac of Nineveh belongs here. So does George MacDonald, which is a fun connection, because C. S. Lewis made MacDonald his guide through the afterlife in The Great Divorce.

    The freedom argument

    David Bentley Hart makes a different kind of case in That All Shall Be Saved as do Thomas Talbott in The Inescapable Love of God and John Kronen and Eric Reitan in God's Final Victory. Their claim is that everyone choosing to be reconciled to God isn't a violation of free will at all, because it would be ludicrous to say that anyone in their right mind is freely choosing infinite pain by resisting their creator.

    God is infinitely drawing humans to himself, and that includes humans who hate God and want nothing to do with him. But the people who hate God and want nothing to do with him aren't in their right mind. They've been twisted by the disease of sin, or greed, or pride, or whatever. And God would not be a very good God if he said, "Well, you are horribly misinformed about the nature of love, goodness, and mercy. Your mind is twisted by evil, and because of that you don't want to be with me. So, goodbye." That does not make for a good God. And, they would argue, that isn't anybody making a truly free choice.

    Behind this is an older idea of what freedom means. For Hart, being free means being able to become what you were made to be. A will that keeps running from the good is sick, and calling that sickness freedom gets things backward.

    Say I tell someone, "If you walk into this room, you'll be mauled by lions and bears." In reality the room is filled with wonderful food and comforts and a spa. If they stay out, they're not making an actually free choice, they're just making a misinformed one. My lie has given them the illusion that they're freely choosing to avoid a room full of bears, and they're missing out on the spa and the good snacks because they were lied to.

    That's the situation of everyone who resists God, on this view. Somebody lied to them: sin, the accuser, every bad picture of God they were ever handed. They don't understand the goodness of God, so they may think they're making some sort of free choice, but they're deceived. As long as there's ignorance or deception or bondage to desire, God can keep working without overriding anyone's freedom, and once those are gone, nobody has a reason left to choose misery.

    So God can only remain good if he does all he can, for as long as he can (and as long as God can = forever), to make sure that the people who are freely choosing a lie no longer think that lie is true.

    Hart still believes in hell, by the way, a purifying one. On the outcome he and Origen agree. Where they differ is the argument: Origen leans on God's patience across the ages, and Hart and Talbott lean on what freedom is.

    Calvinist universalism

    Now jump toward the other end of the line. There's such a thing as deterministic universalism, or Calvinistic universalism. It's basically a form of TULIP. Yes, there's total depravity. But election is unconditional and universal: God chose everybody. Instead of limited atonement, you get universal atonement. Pair that with irresistible grace, and voilà, you're a universalist.

    "Who cares about free will? We're Calvinists," they would say. "Of course, if God wants to save everybody, he'll do whatever the hell he wants."

    This one has quite a bit of history behind it. James Relly, an eighteenth-century Welsh preacher, taught that all of humanity was united to Christ, and his convert John Murray carried that teaching to America, where it helped start the Universalist movement. Friedrich Schleiermacher, often called the father of modern theology, grounded his universalism in one eternal decree by which God elects everyone.

    Barth could belong here too. Matthias Gockel argues that Barth's doctrine of election implies universal salvation, whatever Barth himself was willing to say. If Gockel is right, Barth sits closer to Schleiermacher than to the hopeful crowd.

    Ultra-universalism

    One step past the Calvinists sits Hosea Ballou, the most influential preacher in the second generation of American Universalism. His opponents called his view ultra-universalism. Others called it "death and glory." Ballou taught that everyone goes straight to God at death, with no punishment afterward. Sin is its own punishment, and it gets paid in this life. The dead can't sin anymore, so there's nothing left to punish.

    Plenty of Universalists in Ballou's own movement thought he'd gone too far. These were the restorationists, who believed in a limited time of punishment after death, closer to Origen. The two camps fought about it for years.

    Ballou wasn't a lightweight, and he thought hard about this. But his answer to the injustice question is that your abuser was already punished by being an abuser. I don't think that would satisfy many people who've been harmed.

    Back where we started

    Keep walking past Ballou, past the point where God decides everything and nothing after death answers for anything, and you end up back at pop universalism. All paths lead to God, Christ is optional, and nothing is at stake.

    So the Christian universalisms live between two exits. On one side, freedom gets so absolute that some people are lost for good, locked in or unmade. On the other, sovereignty swallows up freedom and consequences both, until you start to wonder what Jesus was for.

    Further reading

    • David Bentley Hart, That All Shall Be Saved
    • Thomas Talbott, The Inescapable Love of God
    • John Kronen and Eric Reitan, God's Final Victory
    • Hans Urs von Balthasar, Dare We Hope "That All Men Be Saved"?
    • Brad Jersak, Her Gates Will Never Be Shut
    • Gregory MacDonald (ed.), "All Shall Be Well": Explorations in Universal Salvation and Christian Theology, from Origen to Moltmann

    Suggested to read next

    The US Capitol dome at sunrise behind green trees, with the title Some Good in This World

    Some Good in This World

    A letter to The Table Church after the midterms. The past two years have been hard on the world, hard on this country, and hard on Washington in particular. But there's some good in this world, and it's worth fighting for.

    There Must Be Consequences

    Crimes were committed. The Constitution was ignored. Over and over again, judges told the Trump administration that what it was doing was illegal. There must be consequences.

    Black-and-white photo of one person gripping another person's forearm, with the title Dangerous Empathy

    Dangerous Empathy

    A majority of white evangelical Protestants (54%) believe empathy can become dangerous. But the people who think empathy is dangerous are the ones who have abandoned God's truth.